Oilers: Should Pickard Start More?

stores.com Team Editor

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Feb 09, 2025

34 visitor like this post

Share

Oilers: Should Pickard Start More?

The Edmonton Oilers' goaltending situation has been a hot topic of discussion among fans and analysts alike. While Stuart Skinner has solidified himself as the starter, the performance of backup Laurent Brossoit and the potential of prospect Olivier Rodrigue leaves many wondering about the role of another goalie in the mix: Should the Oilers be giving more starts to Calvin Pickard?

The answer, as with most things in hockey, isn't a simple yes or no. It requires a nuanced examination of Pickard's performance, the team's overall goaltending needs, and the broader context of the Oilers' playoff aspirations.

Analyzing Calvin Pickard's Performance

Pickard, a veteran with NHL experience, offers a different skillset compared to Skinner and Brossoit. While his statistics might not jump off the page, his steady presence and experience could be valuable assets. His career highlights demonstrate a capacity for strong performances under pressure. A closer look at his recent games reveals both strengths and areas for improvement:

Strengths:

• Experience: Pickard's time in the NHL provides invaluable experience, especially during crucial moments in games. This can translate into crucial saves and improved team morale.
• Consistency (in limited appearances): While he hasn't had extensive playing time, when given opportunities, he's shown periods of consistent play, making key saves and showcasing strong positioning.
• Leadership: As a seasoned professional, Pickard can provide valuable mentorship to younger goalies within the organization.

Areas for Improvement:

• Playing Time: Lack of consistent playing time can impact a goaltender's rhythm and sharpness. More game action is essential to assessing his true potential.
• Statistics: While not the sole indicator of performance, his overall statistical profile might suggest areas for improvement in puck handling or rebound control.
• Competition for playing time: With Skinner establishing himself as a strong starter and Brossoit's potential role in the team's future, the competition for ice time is fierce.

The Broader Context: Oilers' Goaltending Needs

The Oilers' goaltending needs extend beyond simply finding a reliable starter. The team requires depth and flexibility, especially considering the demanding schedule and potential for injuries. Pickard, in this context, provides a seasoned option as a backup, offering a safety net should Skinner or Brossoit be unavailable.

Considerations:

• Backup Role: His experience makes him a suitable backup goalie, providing a reliable alternative should the starter falter.
• Injury Prevention: Strategic allocation of starts can help prevent goalie burnout and reduce the risk of injury. Rotating Pickard into the lineup, albeit sparingly, could prove beneficial in this regard.
• Development: Providing Pickard with some playing time allows him to stay sharp and maintain a high level of readiness. This can only benefit the team in the long run.

The Verdict: A Calculated Risk?

Giving Pickard more starts is a calculated risk. While his statistics might not be spectacular, his experience and potential value as a backup goaltender should not be discounted. A measured approach is necessary. The Oilers coaching staff must carefully assess the team's needs, the current form of the other goalies, and the potential impact of giving Pickard increased playing time. It's about finding the right balance – optimizing performance while managing risk and preparing for any eventuality. A few more starts to evaluate his current form in a real game situation might prove beneficial. It's all about balancing risk and reward within the overall context of the Oilers' pursuit of playoff success.

Ultimately, the decision of how many starts Pickard receives rests with the Oilers' coaching staff. However, a thorough and objective evaluation of his abilities and the team's overall goaltending needs is crucial to making the right call.